"They say a good chess
player can see up to twenty moves deep. That means that in some games, you've
calculated every possible move in your head. The game's over before it's even
really started”.
–Confidence.
Let us see if we can come up something
close to the above statement, in our field, trading stocks.
A trading strategy, which can factor every
possible scenario! Give us an upper hand to outperform the market.
One doesn’t need to be a genius to
realize the possible outcomes after you buy a stock; stock goes up, stock
goes down or remains flat at the same price, depending on your time
horizon. So all we need to do is capture
the upside and not loose on the down side. This can be done easily by simply
buying puts. But protection is not cheap. If we spend 10% of the underlying
position to buy puts, that will protect us for a year and our position does not
move more than 10% in that time frame, we have lost money.
If I know, my stock is not going to bankrupt,
all I would need is limited protection. If the stock is trading
at $100, instead of protection for $100, all I might need is downside
protection for first $20 or $30. Only way, I can be
confident that my position will not decimate completely is to get into indexes. What are the chances of SPY or IWM going to
zero?
My
ideal portfolio should always maintain cash. If we are fully invested or
borrowed on margin, we panic when the market crashes. On the other hand, we
will see it as an opportunity to increase our position
or open new positions at sale price, if we have cash. At the same time, if the
market is on rise, we will underperform the market
because we are not fully invested. This can be offset by using options.
If I am, a portfolio manager or
running an insurance company, this is how I would invest your one hundred
thousand dollars:
Inception
date: Dec 25, 2011
Symbol
|
Description
|
Quantity
|
Price
|
Value
|
IWM
|
iShares Russell 2000 Index
|
400
|
$74.55
|
$29,820
|
-iwm130119c75
|
IWM Jan2013 75 call
|
5
|
$8.91
|
$4,455
|
-iwm130119c90
|
IWM Jan2013 90 call
|
-9
|
$2.89
|
-$2,601
|
-iwm130119p75
|
IWM Jan2013 75 put
|
6
|
$10.81
|
$6,486
|
-iwm130119p60
|
IWM Jan2013 60 put
|
-10
|
$5.13
|
-$5,013
|
EWZ
|
iShares MSCI Brazil index
|
500
|
$58.33
|
$29,165
|
-ewz130119c58
|
EWZ Jan2013 58 call
|
6
|
$7.75
|
$4,650
|
-ewz130119c70
|
EWZ Jan2013 70 call
|
-11
|
$3.00
|
-$3,300
|
-ewz130119c58
|
EWZ Jan2013 58 put
|
8
|
$8.70
|
$6,960
|
-ewz130119c45
|
EWZ Jan2013 45 put
|
-13
|
$3.90
|
-$5,070
|
Total
|
$65,552
|
Cash Remaining
|
$34,448
|
Total portfolio
|
$100,000
|
Now that I have shown the
portfolio, let us run few scenarios.
Market
is down: Let us assume both IWM and EWZ are down 15%. IWM would be
trading at
$63.37 and EWZ would be trading at $49.58.
IWM position will be worth $25,348 and our 6 puts will be worth $6,708. EWZ
position will be worth $24,790 and our 8 puts will be worth $7,000. Portfolio value will be $98,294 plus
the dividends earned. I would be extremely happy at this situation and also
increase positions with cash on hand.
Market
is up: Let us assume both IWM and EWZ are up 15%. IWM would be
trading at $85.73 and EWZ would be
trading at $67.08. IWM position will be worth $34,292 and our 5 options will be
worth $5,590. EWZ position will be
worth $33,540 and our 6 options will be worth $5,250. Portfolio value
will be $113,120 plus the dividends earned.
Market is flat:
If both positions are flat, we have to close all options and puts two months before expiration
to break even. This was the specific reason, we paired Russell index with Brazil
index.
There was no year, in which both Russell and Brazil index
ended in flat line. If the global economy does not end up in recession
next year, I would bet two cows and three goats that Brazil index would outperform
over the next year.
Market
crashes: If both positions crash 30% our portfolio will be down
around 8% and we will be doubling our core positions, waiting for markets
to rebound. It will hurt that we are down, but will have the pleasure that
our neighbors lost more than us.
I will be tweaking this portfolio
once or twice a year and review the portfolio every Dec 25th
for next four years. You can see how you would have done, if I was your
portfolio manager for five years.
Feel free to leave comments and
poke holes in my strategy, to outperform the markets.
Disclaimer: This
article should not be treated as individual advice. Consult your financial
adviser to review your risk tolerance and strategy that suits you.
Source: Yahoo Finance
Disclosure: I have short and long puts in EWZ
and do not plan on initiating position in IWM in next 72 hours.